How Trump Tariffs Could Affect Toronto Residential Renovation Projects
In an era of economic uncertainty and shifting trade policies, the potential reimplementation or introduction of new tariffs by former U.S. President Donald Trump could have ripple effects across various industries, including residential renovations in Canada. While materials typically account for only 15-20% of total renovation costs, with the remaining 80-85% attributed to labour, even small fluctuations in material prices can influence the overall affordability and feasibility of home improvement projects. The extent to which tariffs could impact the industry depends on several key factors, including trade policies, supply chain logistics, and broader economic repercussions. This article explores the implications of Trump tariffs on Canadian residential renovation projects, dissecting their direct and indirect effects on costs and the housing market as a whole.
Understanding Trump’s Tariffs and Their Impact on Canadian Imports
Historically, Trump has pursued aggressive trade policies, imposing tariffs on various goods and materials from key trading partners, including Canada. During his first presidency, tariffs were placed on aluminum and steel, two critical materials used in construction and home renovation projects. If Trump decides to reinstate or escalate these tariffs, Canadian homeowners and contractors could see a rise in the cost of imported materials.
Since many materials used in Canadian renovation projects—such as lumber, drywall, and specialized fixtures—are sourced from or pass through the U.S., tariffs could lead to increased costs. Even if Canada does not import directly from the U.S., many of its suppliers operate in an interconnected global market, where American trade policies can cause price volatility.
Material Costs and Their Role in Renovation Expenses
While materials account for a relatively small portion of a typical renovation budget (15-20%), any increase in material prices can still have a noticeable impact. A rise in material costs due to tariffs would primarily affect:
Structural Components: Steel framing, aluminum siding, and other foundational materials.
Finishes: Flooring, cabinetry, tiles, and fixtures that may rely on U.S. imports.
Essential Supplies: Drywall, insulation, nails, screws, and adhesives.
For example, if a home renovation project in Toronto is budgeted at $100,000, approximately $15,000 to $20,000 of that would be allocated to materials. If tariffs raise the cost of materials by 20%, that could translate into an additional $3,000 to $4,000 in expenses. While this increase may not be enough to derail a project entirely, it could lead to budget adjustments, downsizing, or seeking alternative material sources.
Indirect Effects on Labour and Overall Renovation Costs
Since labour accounts for 80-85% of a typical renovation budget, the biggest concern for homeowners and contractors is whether tariff-induced inflation will spill over into labour costs. Directly, tariffs do not impact labour expenses, but they could contribute to broader economic changes that influence wages.
Could Labour Costs Rise?
Labour costs are generally influenced by factors such as demand for skilled workers, cost of living, and economic conditions. For tariffs to push up labour costs in Toronto, they would have to trigger a broader inflationary trend that increases the cost of living, particularly housing and essential goods. This could happen in a few ways:
Supply Chain Disruptions: If tariffs make materials more expensive or harder to source, construction projects could slow down, increasing competition for available materials. This could drive up costs and cause ripple effects across the industry.
Inflationary Pressure: Higher costs of materials, combined with potential supply shortages, could contribute to inflation in the broader economy. If inflation rises significantly, workers may demand higher wages to keep up with the increased cost of living.
Increased Demand for Renovations: If tariffs slow down new home construction due to higher costs, more homeowners may opt for renovations instead of moving, increasing demand for skilled tradespeople and potentially raising labour costs due to higher demand.
However, these effects are not guaranteed. If the overall cost of living in Toronto does not rise substantially, labour costs are unlikely to be directly affected by tariffs. Given that the majority of renovation expenses stem from labour, the overall impact of tariffs on total renovation costs may be contained unless inflation takes hold more broadly.
Potential Strategies for Homeowners and Contractors
While tariffs may be beyond the control of homeowners and contractors, there are several strategies to mitigate potential price increases and keep renovation projects on track.
1. Sourcing Alternative Materials
If tariffs are imposed on U.S. imports, Canadian contractors may explore alternative suppliers from other countries or domestic manufacturers. Buying Canadian-made materials can help reduce reliance on tariff-impacted imports and stabilize costs.
2. Planning Ahead and Locking in Prices
Homeowners considering renovations should plan their projects in advance and lock in prices where possible. Suppliers and contractors may offer fixed-price contracts for materials, helping to shield against future cost increases.
3. Adjusting Project Scope and Material Choices
If material costs rise significantly, homeowners may need to adjust their renovation plans. Opting for alternative materials, repurposing existing materials, or phasing projects over time can help manage costs.
4. Monitoring Market Trends
Staying informed about trade policies, material costs, and market trends can help homeowners and contractors make strategic decisions. If tariffs seem likely to be implemented, accelerating renovation plans before price hikes take effect may be a wise move.
Conclusion
What to Expect Moving Forward
While the potential for Trump-imposed tariffs could impact material costs in Canada, the overall effect on residential renovation projects is likely to be limited unless inflation drives up labour costs. Since materials only account for 15-20% of total renovation expenses, any increase due to tariffs would be a fraction of the overall budget. Homeowners and contractors can take proactive steps to minimize these effects, such as sourcing alternative materials and planning projects strategically.
Ultimately, the biggest risk to renovation affordability is not just tariffs themselves but their potential to contribute to broader economic inflation. If the cost of living in Toronto rises significantly, then labour costs could follow suit, making renovations more expensive across the board. For now, careful planning and market awareness remain key to managing any potential tariff-related cost increases.
Meet the Author
Dave Cook is co-owner of Lighthaus Built and has spent 17 years working in single-family construction in Toronto. Through the years, he has worked as a carpenter, site supervisor, and project manager for more than 60+ major, high-end renovations and custom homes.
As an HCRA-licensed builder, he and his company (Lighthaus Built) are well-versed in constructing high-quality homes and take pride in what they do.
On a personal level, Dave is very active in several sports - most notably, distance running, road cycling, and tennis. He bakes bread (for personal consumption) and no, this was not a Covid thing. He grew up eating homemade bread and has made my own for the past 20 years. He has been married for 20 years and has two teenage children and a dog.
Lighthaus Built’s
FREE Toronto Renovation Cost Guide
Are you considering a home addition or full home renovation and not sure how to budget for it?
Our free guide walks you through over 50 topics and how the cost of materials, labour and design ranges so you can plan for your Design-Build home renovation in Toronto.